What is the difference between completed contract and percentage of completion accounting?
Completed contract accounting waits until a project is finished to recognize any revenue or profit. You might spend six months on a job, bill progress payments throughout, and carry significant costs. None of it shows as income until the project is complete. Then the entire profit or loss hits your books in that final period.
Percentage of completion works as the name suggests. As you finish portions of a project, you recognize that portion of revenue and costs. If you’ve incurred 60% of expected costs on a job, you recognize 60% of expected revenue. Your financial statements show work in progress rather than nothing until completion.
The tax timing difference is significant. A contractor using completed contract on a project that starts in November and finishes in March can defer all income to the following tax year. The same project under percentage of completion would split income between both years based on work performed in each period.
Not every contractor gets to choose. The IRS requires percentage of completion for larger construction businesses. The small contractor exception allows completed contract for businesses averaging $29 million or less in gross receipts over the prior three years. Below that threshold, you typically have flexibility.
Each method has practical tradeoffs beyond taxes. Completed contract is simpler to manage in your books since you’re not calculating completion percentages or estimating total costs throughout the project. But it creates lumpy financial statements where one quarter might show minimal revenue and the next shows several completed projects hitting at once.
Banks and bonding companies often prefer percentage of completion because it shows a more accurate picture of ongoing work. If you’re pursuing larger contracts that require bonding, your financial statements need to reflect work in progress. Showing nothing until completion understates the value of contracts you’re actively performing.
The calculation for percentage of completion requires accurate job costing. You need to track costs by project and estimate total expected costs reliably. If your cost tracking is loose, the revenue recognition becomes unreliable. Garbage cost data produces garbage financial statements.
Switching between methods isn’t something you do casually. The IRS treats it as a change in accounting method requiring formal approval. If you’ve been using one method and want to change, talk to a Boise area enrolled agent who understands construction accounting before making that decision.
For most smaller contractors, completed contract offers simplicity and potential tax deferral. For those needing strong financials for bonding or bank relationships, percentage of completion provides a more accurate ongoing picture. The right choice depends on your business size, bonding needs, and how well you track job costs.
The Treasure Valley's Tax and Accounting Team
The Next Step:
A Short Conversation
Tell us what you're dealing with. We'll listen, answer your questions, and give you a straightforward quote.
More Questions
How do I choose between standard and itemized deductions?
Pick whichever one is higher. Add up your itemized deductions and compare them to the standard deduction for your filing status. Most people take the standard deduction because the 2017 tax law nearly doubled it.
Read answerCan a bookkeeper help me set up QuickBooks?
Yes, a bookkeeper can help you set up QuickBooks correctly from the start. Professional setup includes building a proper chart of accounts, connecting bank feeds, and configuring settings that match how your business actually operates.
Read answerWhat is prime cost and how do I track it?
Prime cost is your cost of goods sold plus total labor costs, expressed as a percentage of sales. For restaurants, it's the single most important number for understanding profitability. Track it weekly by monitoring food costs and all-in labor expenses.
Read answerWhich QuickBooks version is best for small businesses?
QuickBooks Online Plus works for most small businesses because it includes job tracking and inventory. The right choice depends on what you need to track, not just what costs less.
Read answerWhat is progress billing and how do I track it?
Progress billing lets contractors invoice customers incrementally as work gets completed instead of waiting until project end. Track it by setting up jobs in your accounting software with the total contract value and generating invoices against that estimate as milestones are reached.
Read answerShould I form an LLC or sole proprietorship?
It depends on your liability exposure, expected income, and growth plans. An LLC costs $100 in Idaho and provides liability protection plus future tax flexibility. A sole proprietorship is simpler but offers no asset protection.
Read answer
